New York City

Review: Should you Book the East Village Pizza Tour

by Paul Joseph  |  Published December 9, 2024

This themed tour of New York’s East Village lets you dive into the city’s rich pizza heritage while tasting some standout pies.

(Photo: Scott’s Pizza Tours / Courtesy GetYourGuide)

If you find yourself in the East Village, pizza’s bound to be on your mind. The neighborhood’s pizza joints have been around long enough to have a few stories to tell. On this walk, you’ll pop into a mix of  eateries, from those that have been slinging pies for years to newer places making their mark on the long-standing pizza scene. It’s not just about eating – it’s about seeing how the area’s pizza culture has shifted over time, all while grabbing a slice or two.  So what’s our verdict on the tour? Read our review below.

About the tour

This walking tour is run by Scott’s Pizza Tours, a local company that shares the stories behind New York’s legendary pizza scene to a conveyer belt of hungry patrons. The tour takes you through the lively East Village, where you’ll stop at three standout local pizzerias to try some of the home-made slices. Along the way, you’ll sample everything from classic New York-style creations to some quirkier varieties that showcase just how diverse pizza can be. Each stop comes with a side of history, as your guide explains how these spots have shaped – and been shaped by – the city’s love affair with the humble but oh-so-delicious pizza.

It’s a group tour, but with no more than 16 people, it still feels personal and laid-back. Your guide is not just there to navigate – they’re hired on the basis of being an unabashed pizza nerd, sharing fun facts about the art of pizza-making and the East Village’s history as you go. They also go the extra mile to keep things engaging as you stroll between stops, pointing out interesting landmarks and adding some local flavor to the walk.

The tour wraps up near Tompkins Square Park, where you can hang out and let all those doughy treats settle, or plot your next adventure. From here, you could dive into some of the neighborhood’s quirky shops, chill in a cafe, or – in the unlikely event hat you’re still craving pizza—hunt down another slice.

Evaluation

The East Village Pizza Tour by Scott’s Pizza Tours receives mainly positive feedback as a fun and engaging experience. The tour takes you to three pizzerias, each offering something a little different, and guests seem to love the variety of slices you get to try, which range from classic, no-frills margaritas to more experimental concoctions. And by limiting the samples to just one slice per stop, there’s enough to give you a real taste (literally) of the city’s pizza diversity without leaving you in a carb coma.

Another plus point is the quality of the guides, who are commended for their obsessional pizza knowledge and knack for weaving pizza trivia with local history, so even while you’re munching, you’re learning. That said, there’s a decent amount of walking, and if you’re someone who prefers to sit and linger, it might feel a little ‘on the go’. The pace isn’t hectic, but it’s definitely designed to keep things moving.

This tour isn’t just for die-hard pizza lovers; it’s also likely to be a hit with people who simply enjoy a mix of food and history. It’s casual, social and suitable for couples, small groups, or even solo travelers looking for a fun way to spend a few hours. Families with older kids would probably enjoy it too, but younger ones might struggle with the walking and history input.

Overall, if you’re  in New York and are into pizza with a side-helping of quirky local history, this tour’s a bit of a no-brainer. It’s affordable and a great way to eat like a true New Yorker while exploring one the city’s most vibrant neighborhoods. Just be sure to bring your appetite – and some comfy shoes.

Practical info

The tour lasts around 2.5 to 3 hours and runs regularly, typically in the afternoons and evenings. Participants are asked to assemble at a central meeting point in the East Village, with the exact location provided upon booking. It’s a walking tour, so be prepared for some light strolling as you visit several pizzerias in the area. The walking distance is manageable, but comfortable footwear is recommended.

Tickets for the tour generally range from $50 to $60 per person, and while kids are welcome, the tour is best suited for those who can comfortably walk and appreciate food-focused experiences. Food and drinks are included, as you’ll get to sample a variety of pizzas from each stop. It’s also a good idea to wear weather-appropriate clothing since the tour runs rain or shine.

You can book the the East Village Pizza Tour at GetYourGuide